Perchance to Dream: Robin Hanson on Sleep-Rape
Robin Hanson thinks sexsomniacs (people who have sex in a sleepwalking state) should be punished just like regular rapists when they (unknowingly) begin to have sex with someone who does not consent. To be clear: rape is a heinous thing and, along with murder, stands in my mind as an essentially peerless crime. There are few, if any, more fundamental or horrifying ways in which to violate another human being. Perhaps it was Hanson’s use of the imperative in his title (“Punish Sleep-Rape”) that rankled me.
To justify his point, he devises two possible arguments against punishment of sexsomniac rapists:
- We should punish premeditated or intentional transgressions more severely than we would unconscious transgressions.
- The mind is comprised of two distinct states: the conscious and the unconscious. Thus, behaviors emanating from conscious processes should be punished more severely.
Hanson goes on to summarily dismiss both of these imagined arguments, presumably without … Read more





